Updates

Festival: what we heard

Thank you to everyone who came to the Castlemaine Festival for Democracy and shared their views. Here's a short summary of what you told us.
Hosted with
Date
-
Location
Price
$
Register your interest
If we get enough interest we'll organise an event.
Posted by:
Bryn Davies
November 19, 2026
November 19, 2026

147 people joined the live polling on the day. This is a short summary of what you told us: who was in the room, why people came, how much change people think our democracy needs, and who we still need to hear from.

Who was in the room

62% of those who answered live in Mount Alexander Shire, most of them in Castlemaine. Others came from Melbourne, regional Victoria, interstate and even overseas.

In Castlemaine42% · 31 of 74
Elsewhere in Mount Alexander Shire20% · 15 of 74
Melbourne12% · 9 of 74
Elsewhere in Victoria16% · 12 of 74
Interstate7% · 5 of 74
Overseas3% · 2 of 74

The largest number of people were 35–49. Nonetheless, the room leaned older. 43% were 60 or over and 10% were under 35.

Under 253% · 2 of 80
25 to 34 years8% · 6 of 80
35 to 49 years28% · 22 of 80
50 to 59 years20% · 16 of 80
60 to 69 years24% · 19 of 80
70 to 84 years19% · 15 of 80

Why people came

85% came hopeful and wanting to be part of change, and 80% were worried about the state of our democracy.

Hopeful, want to be part of the change85% · 71 of 84
Worried about the state of our democracy80% · 67 of 84
Curious, want to learn more65% · 55 of 84
Work in this space40% · 34 of 84
Want to get involved: volunteer or join27% · 23 of 84
Other5% · 4 of 84
A relative or friend made me come2% · 2 of 84

Note: people could choose more than one reason, so these add to more than 100%.

How much change people want

56% think our democratic system needs fundamental redesign but very few wanted to throw it out and start again: people want serious change to the system we have. Nobody chose "It's all fine", and only 5 of 90 said our democratic system is mostly good and just needs tweaking.

Throw it out and start again3% · 3 of 90
Fundamental redesign56% · 50 of 90
Needs some renovation36% · 32 of 90
Mostly good but could do with tweaking6% · 5 of 90
It's all fine0% · 0 of 90

Three examples of citizen-led democracy

In the morning sessions, people explored one of three examples: the Mount Alexander People's Assembly, Voices for Bendigo or West End Resilience. 62 of 75 said the example they explored was something they could get involved in (many of the "not sure" answers came from people who live outside the area and want to take the ideas home).

YesNot sureNo
Mount Alexander People's Assembly82% yes · 33 people
Voices for Bendigo72% yes · 25 people
West End Resilience100% yes · 17 people
All three models83% yes · 75 people

Who might be left out

We asked who might find it hard to take part in the three examples shared. 63 people named groups and barriers. Time, work, caring and cost-of-living pressures came up most (37% of answers); followed by confidence: the quieter people, and those who feel "politics isn't for me" (30%).

Time, work, caring and cost of living37% · 23 answers
Confidence, or feeling "politics isn't for me"30% · 19 answers
Access: timing, venue, transport, disability17% · 11 answers
Social isolation and division16% · 10 answers
Digital access, literacy and language14% · 9 answers
Cultural safety: First Nations, migrant and multicultural communities14% · 9 answers
Being seen as one side of politics10% · 6 answers
Disadvantage and marginalisation10% · 6 answers
Young people and families6% · 4 answers

Themes are a rough grouping of the written answers. One answer can touch several themes.

A few responses worth highlighting:

Believing you have the right/responsibility likely a privileged experience.
The initial committee/founders are very progressive. Need some leadership early who sit across the political spectrum.
Time, access, language, literacy, all these can be worked with. None are a reason to stop.

What else people said

  • Go slow and stick at it. "Persistence pays. This is a marathon. Make it fun." Relationships and listening come before solutions.
  • Share what you learn. People from other towns and cities want to learn from this and try it where they live.
  • Design carefully. Recruitment, getting the question right, timing, and how topics are chosen all came up. One person suggested paying participants.
  • Don't leave it to the usual few. The work of carrying outcomes forward shouldn't fall on the same handful of community organisers.
  • Reach beyond the people already on board. The room wasn't representative, and building trust will mean reaching people who weren't there, and working with all levels of government and other groups.
This Assembly needs to balance drawing on global best practice and designing something that is organically and authentically of THIS place.

What people asked the speakers

27 questions were put to the morning panel. The most upvoted were about money and lobbyists in politics, exciting new ways of doing democracy, and how to reach the people who feel disengaged.

QuestionUpvotes
Can democracy overcome money politics and the influence of lobbyists?19
What’s the most exciting example or idea about doing democracy differently that you’ve heard about this year?17
How do we engage the 85% disengaged?14
as someone who has also worked as a journo what is the role of media in democracy and what would you say about state of media in australia?9
What’s your advice for young women wanting to run?6
What was the key to gathering 2000 community volunteers?5
How can we make all of the democratic process more joyful?4
Do you have faith in representative democracy as opposed to participatory decision making?3

A selection of the most upvoted questions, as written.

What happens next

What you told us will shape the Mount Alexander People's Assembly. The design group starts work in December, and recruitment begins next year. A few pieces of advice we are taking away:

  • Reach the people who weren't in the room: younger people, carers, people working long or irregular hours, and people in the smaller towns.
  • Make taking part practical, through timing, venues, childcare and support for people's time.
  • Keep it non-partisan and open to everyone, with people from across the political spectrum involved early.
  • Share what we learn so others can build on it.

To stay in touch, sign up at reallylocal.au.

About these results

These results come from the live polling used on the day. Answers were anonymous, and no names or contact details are included. Not everyone answered every question, so each figure has its own base: 108 people answered at least one poll, 90 answered the question on change, and 75 completed the survey on the three examples. The people who answered chose to come to the festival, so this is a picture of the room, not of Mount Alexander Shire as a whole.